Trusted, tried and true pantry staple

Beth Kuchynka • May 30, 2025

Olive oil has been part of Mediterranean life for thousands of years. It's more than a cooking fat—it's culture, health, and history in a bottle. As Americans we've been a bit slow to catch on...


Why Olive Oil?
Unlike butter or seed oils, extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) is rich in heart-healthy monounsaturated fats—especially oleic acid, which is stable, heat-tolerant, and linked to lower inflammation. EVOO also offers small but mighty doses of omega-3s, vitamin E, and polyphenols—plant compounds that fight oxidation (a fancy way of saying aging and disease).


The Secret’s in the Harvest
The health benefits and flavor of olive oil depend on how and when the olives are picked. Early harvest, same-day pressing, and minimal oxygen exposure protect the oil’s delicate antioxidants and prevent rancidity. That’s why oils from our producers—like Trampetti, Mannucci-Droandi, and San Basilio—are pressed within hours and stored in stainless steel tanks. You can taste the difference: green, bright, peppery, and alive.

Polyphenols: Olive Oil’s Superpower
Polyphenols do double duty—protecting your body and the oil itself. They keep it fresher longer, resist heat degradation, and even reduce the formation of harmful compounds when cooking meat. Fun fact: tomatoes cooked in olive oil deliver more antioxidants than when cooked in sunflower oil.

About That “Extra Virgin” Label
Legally, EVOO must have less than 0.8% acidity. Our favorite producers aim much lower—think 0.2–0.3%. It’s a sign of freshness and careful handling. High acidity? It usually means the olives sat too long or were damaged before pressing.

Cooking vs. Finishing?
Most people save their best oils for salads—but it's actually the high-quality oils that hold up best under heat. Oleic acid is far more stable than the polyunsaturated fats in seed oils. So yes, you can (and should) cook with the good stuff.


How to Spot the Good Stuff

  • Dark bottles only: Light degrades oil.
  • Know your source: Look for a named farm or press (Frantoio), not vague phrases like “Bottled in Italy.”
  • Harvest date matters: Fresher is better.
  • Pay for quality: Hand-harvested oils cost more—and are worth it.


One Kitchen, Many Oils
Each oil has its place. Some are soft and buttery, others grassy and bold. The best way to discover is through taste! Join us June 22 for a delicious deep dive into the world of Italian olive oil with Ilyse Rathet — owner of Ritrovo and a Slow Food Master of Olive Oil. 


Tickets  Here.

By Beth Kuchynka March 26, 2026
Such a fun time.
bayleaf celebrating 25 years.
By Beth Kuchynka October 18, 2025
Can you believe it?
By Beth Kuchynka June 9, 2025
Which Pour Are You Coming For? Wine Club Members 2 for 1 Discounts offered on purchases seated as a group, food available for purchase Thursdays 5-7 tickets here
By Beth Kuchynka April 22, 2025
We’ve just received word that prices will increase on May 1, so we’re putting together one last order at the current pricing. This is your chance to scoop up any legacy favorites you’ve been eyeing—or discover something new in their gorgeous 2025 catalog (you can browse it here ).
By Beth Kuchynka April 15, 2025
Join us for a special seated tasting on Thursday, May 15 from 5–7 PM with Clarke Boehling of Rosenthal Wine Merchant While visiting trade accounts in the area, Clarke has carved out time to lead this intimate tasting—and we’re thrilled to host him. This is a rare chance to explore the Rosenthal portfolio through the eyes (and palate) of someone who knows it inside and out. Tickets here .
By Beth Kuchynka November 18, 2024
 Below are the wines poured at this year's Annual Champagne Tasting. Please reach out with interest.
By Beth Kuchynka October 29, 2024
Success!
By Beth Kuchynka May 15, 2024
Amazing
By Beth Kuchynka April 18, 2024
Spring Cleaning?
several glasses of champagne are lined up in a row
By Beth Kuchynka October 31, 2023
Really there is so much to know.
More Posts